{"url":"https://policetransparencynj.com/departments/nutley-pd/","summary":"Nutley Police Department logged 105 internal affairs investigations in 2025 involving 58 officers named in those cases. Its rate of 181 per 100 officers exceeded the Essex County median of 158.6 and the 125.9 statewide municipal median, a spread that can indicate more misconduct or a department that opens files on more complaints. Of the 105 investigations detailed for 2025, 13 reported sustained complaints. Other Departmental Rule Violation was the leading allegation category, followed by Harassment/Stalking and Other Criminal Violation. Allegations are not findings.\n\nTwo major discipline records appear across the 2020-2025 releases, both from 2024. Nutley PD received a C on the report card, at the 59th percentile among 93 peers in the 60+ officers group, a high-confidence grade.","note":"Compiled from New Jersey Attorney General public data by an independent project; not a government source. Every value is as reported, with its sourceRef. Method: https://policetransparencynj.com/methodology/","data":{"agency":{"id":"nutley-pd","slug":"nutley-pd","name":"Nutley PD","fullName":"Nutley Police Department","countySlug":"essex","countyName":"Essex","type":"municipal-pd","aliases":["Nutley PD-Essex","Nutley PD|Essex"]},"totalsByYear":[{"agencyId":"nutley-pd","countySlug":"essex","countyName":"Essex","year":2021,"officers":39,"investigations":84,"incidents":44,"sourceRef":{"file":"ia-agency-totals","sheet":"Sheet1","row":198}},{"agencyId":"nutley-pd","countySlug":"essex","countyName":"Essex","year":2022,"officers":42,"investigations":68,"incidents":41,"sourceRef":{"file":"ia-agency-totals","sheet":"Sheet1","row":1212}},{"agencyId":"nutley-pd","countySlug":"essex","countyName":"Essex","year":2023,"officers":38,"investigations":56,"incidents":30,"sourceRef":{"file":"ia-agency-totals","sheet":"Sheet1","row":1721}},{"agencyId":"nutley-pd","countySlug":"essex","countyName":"Essex","year":2024,"officers":43,"investigations":77,"incidents":43,"sourceRef":{"file":"ia-agency-totals","sheet":"Sheet1","row":704}},{"agencyId":"nutley-pd","countySlug":"essex","countyName":"Essex","year":2025,"officers":58,"investigations":105,"incidents":48,"sourceRef":{"file":"ia-agency-totals","sheet":"Sheet1","row":2227}}],"mdRecords":[{"id":"john-mecka-nutley-pd-r1077","year":2024,"countyName":"Essex","countySlug":"essex","agencyId":"nutley-pd","rank":"Officer","firstName":"John","lastName":"Mecka","officerSlug":"john-mecka-nutley-pd","terminated":"no","demoted":"no","suspended":"yes","daysSuspended":8,"separatedWhileIAPending":"no","otherSanction":"Training coaching or counseling","sustainedCharges":"3:1.1 Standards of Conduct and Nutley Police Policy Body Worn Cameras","description":"Officer Mecka, while assisting with an investigation, proceeded to make a variety of unprofessional remarks. Officer Mecka also made a statement implying that a superior officer had a diminished mental capacity, and he deactivated his body worn camera prior to the incidents conclusion. Officer Mecka was issued a Final Notice of Disciplinary Action imposing an eight-day suspension.","sourceRef":{"file":"major-discipline-2020-2025","sheet":"Major Discipline Data","row":1077}},{"id":"robert-mcdermott-nutley-pd-r1078","year":2024,"countyName":"Essex","countySlug":"essex","agencyId":"nutley-pd","rank":"Sergeant","firstName":"Robert","lastName":"McDermott","officerSlug":"robert-mcdermott-nutley-pd","terminated":"no","demoted":"no","suspended":"yes","daysSuspended":120,"separatedWhileIAPending":"no","otherSanction":"Training coaching or counseling","sustainedCharges":"3:1.11 (Obedience to Laws and Regulations) and 3:6.1 (Conduct Toward the Public)","description":"Sergeant McDermott, while on desk duty, proceeded to enter the victim’s lounge and engage in conversation with a friend of his who was applying for a TRO against his girlfriend. During their conversation, Sergeant McDermott made statements portraying women in a negative light, which he later claimed were made solely in an attempt to cheer up his friend. On a separate occasion, Sergeant McDermott engaged in an argument in connection with an individual with a TRO he was assisting in obtaining personal items from his residence. The disciplinary matters were consolidated and the Township retained an independent hearing officer. The hearing officer concluded that Sergeant McDermott’s statements were unprofessional, but that the evidence presented strongly outweighed any claim that he is bias against women. Sergeant McDermott was issued a Final Notice of Disciplinary Action imposing the Hearing Officer’s recommended penalty of a 120-day suspension, with 25 days served/forfeit and 95 days held in abeyance. Sergeant McDermott was also required to undergo individual counseling/therapy.","sourceRef":{"file":"major-discipline-2020-2025","sheet":"Major Discipline Data","row":1078}}],"benchmark":{"year":2025,"investigationsPer100Officers":181.0344827586207,"countyMedianPer100":158.57142857142856,"statewideTypeMedianPer100":125.92592592592592,"countyPeerCount":22,"statewideTypePeerCount":445},"iaDetailByYear":[{"agencyId":"nutley-pd","countySlug":"essex","countyName":"Essex","year":2021,"investigations":84,"allegations":{"Other Departmental Rule Violation":66,"Demeanor":9,"Improper Arrest":2,"Differential Treatment":7},"internalDispositions":{"Sustained":14,"not_provided":6,"Administratively Closed":5,"Unfounded":5,"Not Sustained":13,"Exonerated":41},"sustainedInvestigations":0,"sourceRef":{"file":"ia-download-2021-2023","sheet":"Sheet1","row":1}},{"agencyId":"nutley-pd","countySlug":"essex","countyName":"Essex","year":2022,"investigations":68,"allegations":{"Conduct Unbecoming/Discredit To The Agency":4,"Other Departmental Rule Violation":13,"Preventable MV accident":2,"False Documentation/Falsifying A Report (Non-Criminal)":7,"Neglect of duty":12,"Vehicular Pursuit Policy Violation":2,"Drug Test Failure":1,"Improper Entry":6,"Excessive Force":2,"Demeanor":6,"BWC/MVR Violation":1,"Improper Arrest":6,"Theft":1,"Attendance issues":1,"Improper Supervision/Failure To Supervise":2,"Differential Treatment":1,"Assault":1},"internalDispositions":{"Sustained":17,"Not Sustained":3,"Exonerated":13,"Unfounded":8,"Administratively Closed":6,"not_provided":21},"sustainedInvestigations":17,"sourceRef":{"file":"ia-download-2021-2023","sheet":"Sheet1","row":1}},{"agencyId":"nutley-pd","countySlug":"essex","countyName":"Essex","year":2023,"investigations":56,"allegations":{"Other Departmental Rule Violation":13,"Demeanor":10,"Differential Treatment":3,"Neglect of Duty":6,"Improper Arrest":7,"Improper Supervision/Failure to Supervise":6,"Conduct Unbecoming/Discredit To The Agency":3,"False Documentation/Falsifying A Report (Non-Criminal)":1,"not_provided":2,"Excessive Force":1,"Harassment/Stalking":2,"Vehicular Pursuit Policy Violation":1,"Drug Test Failure":1},"internalDispositions":{"not_provided":13,"Not Sustained":6,"Sustained":14,"Unfounded":17,"Exonerated":6},"sustainedInvestigations":14,"sourceRef":{"file":"ia-download-2021-2023","sheet":"Sheet1","row":1}},{"agencyId":"nutley-pd","countySlug":"essex","countyName":"Essex","year":2024,"investigations":77,"allegations":{"Other Departmental Rule Violation":16,"Conduct Unbecoming/Discredit To The Agency":6,"Assault":1,"Demeanor":12,"Vehicular Pursuit Policy Violation":1,"Differential Treatment":8,"Drug Test Failure":3,"Improper Arrest":4,"Improper Supervision/Failure To Supervise":1,"Harassment/Stalking":14,"Neglect of Duty":4,"False Documentation/Falsifying A Report (Non-Criminal)":2,"False Documentation/Falsifying A Report (Criminal)":1,"Other Criminal Violation":4},"internalDispositions":{"Exonerated":18,"Sustained":14,"Not Sustained":5,"Unfounded":11,"not_provided":29},"sustainedInvestigations":14,"sourceRef":{"file":"ia-investigations-2024-2025","sheet":"Sheet1","row":1}},{"agencyId":"nutley-pd","countySlug":"essex","countyName":"Essex","year":2025,"investigations":105,"allegations":{"Demeanor":14,"Other Departmental Rule Violation":24,"Differential Treatment":5,"Insubordination/Disobeying An Order":1,"not_provided":1,"Assault":1,"Improper Entry":4,"Improper Arrest":5,"Other Criminal Violation":17,"Harassment/Stalking":20,"Domestic violence (Non-Criminal)":2,"Conduct Unbecoming/Discredit To The Agency":2,"False Documentation/Falsifying A Report (Criminal)":2,"Theft":2,"Drug Test Failure":2,"Neglect of Duty":2,"Sexual Assault/Criminal Sexual Violation":1},"internalDispositions":{"Exonerated":22,"Unfounded":3,"Administratively Closed":2,"Not Sustained":9,"Sustained":13,"not_provided":56},"sustainedInvestigations":13,"sourceRef":{"file":"ia-investigations-2024-2025","sheet":"Sheet1","row":1}}],"officersInvolvedByYear":{"2024":77,"2025":104},"nonReportingYears":[]}}