{"url":"https://policetransparencynj.com/departments/south-orange-pd/","summary":"South Orange Police Department reported 35 internal affairs investigations in 2025 and 19 officers named in those cases, a rate of 184.2 per 100 officers. The Essex County median was 158.6 and the statewide municipal median was 125.9. A rate that far above the medians can reflect a heavier volume of misconduct or a department that records more of the complaints brought to it. Of the 35 investigations detailed for 2025, 10 reported sustained complaints. Other Departmental Rule Violation was the leading allegation category, with Demeanor and Differential Treatment also prominent. Allegations are not findings.\n\nFour major discipline records appear across the 2020-2025 releases, from 2021, 2024 and 2025. South Orange received an F on the report card, at the 81st percentile among 111 peers in the 30-59 officers group, a high-confidence grade.","note":"Compiled from New Jersey Attorney General public data by an independent project; not a government source. Every value is as reported, with its sourceRef. Method: https://policetransparencynj.com/methodology/","data":{"agency":{"id":"south-orange-pd","slug":"south-orange-pd","name":"South Orange PD","fullName":"South Orange Police Department","countySlug":"essex","countyName":"Essex","type":"municipal-pd","aliases":["South Orange PD-Essex","South Orange PD|Essex"]},"totalsByYear":[{"agencyId":"south-orange-pd","countySlug":"essex","countyName":"Essex","year":2021,"officers":18,"investigations":19,"incidents":19,"sourceRef":{"file":"ia-agency-totals","sheet":"Sheet1","row":201}},{"agencyId":"south-orange-pd","countySlug":"essex","countyName":"Essex","year":2022,"officers":23,"investigations":41,"incidents":41,"sourceRef":{"file":"ia-agency-totals","sheet":"Sheet1","row":1215}},{"agencyId":"south-orange-pd","countySlug":"essex","countyName":"Essex","year":2023,"officers":30,"investigations":44,"incidents":44,"sourceRef":{"file":"ia-agency-totals","sheet":"Sheet1","row":1724}},{"agencyId":"south-orange-pd","countySlug":"essex","countyName":"Essex","year":2024,"officers":22,"investigations":40,"incidents":40,"sourceRef":{"file":"ia-agency-totals","sheet":"Sheet1","row":707}},{"agencyId":"south-orange-pd","countySlug":"essex","countyName":"Essex","year":2025,"officers":19,"investigations":35,"incidents":35,"sourceRef":{"file":"ia-agency-totals","sheet":"Sheet1","row":2230}}],"mdRecords":[{"id":"matthew-dsurney-south-orange-pd-r339","year":2025,"countyName":"Essex","countySlug":"essex","agencyId":"south-orange-pd","rank":"Officer","firstName":"Matthew","lastName":"Dsurney","officerSlug":"matthew-dsurney-south-orange-pd","terminated":"no","demoted":"no","suspended":"yes","daysSuspended":5,"separatedWhileIAPending":"no","otherSanction":"Loss of time","sustainedCharges":"Insubordination","description":"A charge of insubordination was sustained against Officer Dsurney after he was found to be using a personal device (cell phone) for official police business (documenting case notes). The officer was previously disciplined for using the same personal device to take photos during a call for service and ordered to cease using any personal devices for evidentiary purposes. For the purposes of major discipline reporting, it should be noted that the officer's shift is 12 hours long thus a five-day suspension equals 60 hours of lost time.","sourceRef":{"file":"major-discipline-2020-2025","sheet":"Major Discipline Data","row":339}},{"id":"matthew-dsurney-south-orange-pd-r1082","year":2024,"countyName":"Essex","countySlug":"essex","agencyId":"south-orange-pd","rank":"Officer","firstName":"Matthew","lastName":"Dsurney","officerSlug":"matthew-dsurney-south-orange-pd","terminated":"no","demoted":"no","suspended":"yes","daysSuspended":4,"separatedWhileIAPending":"no","otherSanction":"not_applicable","sustainedCharges":"SOPD Rules & Regulations 4:1-1 Standard of Conduct/NJ Title 4A:2-2.3(a)(6) Conduct Unbecoming","description":"Officer Dsurney, while in the communications room at police headquarters, used or accessed the desk commander's computer in the commander's absence and where he had no duty, reason or permission to do so. For the purposes of major discipline reporting, it shall be noted that the officer's shift is 12 hours long thus a four-day suspension equals 48 hours of lost time which triggers said reporting.","sourceRef":{"file":"major-discipline-2020-2025","sheet":"Major Discipline Data","row":1082}},{"id":"michael-cucciniello-south-orange-pd-r2557","year":2021,"countyName":"Essex","countySlug":"essex","agencyId":"south-orange-pd","rank":"Sergeant","firstName":"Michael","lastName":"Cucciniello","officerSlug":"michael-cucciniello-south-orange-pd","terminated":"no","demoted":"yes","suspended":"yes","daysSuspended":60,"separatedWhileIAPending":"not_applicable","otherSanction":"not_reported","sustainedCharges":"Incompetency, Inefficiency, or Failure to Perform Duties","description":"Sergeant Cucciniello was demoted for failing to promptly prepare a police report related to a serious incident.","sourceRef":{"file":"major-discipline-2020-2025","sheet":"Major Discipline Data","row":2557}},{"id":"darrell-terry-south-orange-pd-r2558","year":2021,"countyName":"Essex","countySlug":"essex","agencyId":"south-orange-pd","rank":"Officer","firstName":"Darrell","lastName":"Terry","officerSlug":"darrell-terry-south-orange-pd","terminated":"no","demoted":"no","suspended":"yes","daysSuspended":8,"separatedWhileIAPending":"not_applicable","otherSanction":"not_reported","sustainedCharges":"Conduct Unbecoming","description":"Officer Terry was suspended for 8 days for off duty conduct during a South Orange Police Department investigation of a local ordinance violation.","sourceRef":{"file":"major-discipline-2020-2025","sheet":"Major Discipline Data","row":2558}}],"benchmark":{"year":2025,"investigationsPer100Officers":184.21052631578948,"countyMedianPer100":158.57142857142856,"statewideTypeMedianPer100":125.92592592592592,"countyPeerCount":22,"statewideTypePeerCount":445},"iaDetailByYear":[{"agencyId":"south-orange-pd","countySlug":"essex","countyName":"Essex","year":2021,"investigations":19,"allegations":{"Other Departmental Rule Violation":6,"Differential Treatment":2,"Demeanor":7,"Other Criminal Violation":4},"internalDispositions":{"Sustained":3,"not_provided":3,"Unfounded":3,"Exonerated":5,"Administratively Closed":4,"Not Sustained":1},"sustainedInvestigations":0,"sourceRef":{"file":"ia-download-2021-2023","sheet":"Sheet1","row":1}},{"agencyId":"south-orange-pd","countySlug":"essex","countyName":"Essex","year":2022,"investigations":41,"allegations":{"Demeanor":10,"Differential Treatment":3,"Insubordination/Disobeying An Order":4,"Neglect of duty":5,"Other Departmental Rule Violation":15,"Loss Of Or Failure To Safeguard Agency Propert":1,"Conduct Unbecoming/Discredit To The Agency":1,"BWC/MVR Violation":1,"Vehicular Pursuit Policy Violation":1},"internalDispositions":{"Not Sustained":9,"Sustained":17,"Exonerated":12,"Administratively Closed":3},"sustainedInvestigations":17,"sourceRef":{"file":"ia-download-2021-2023","sheet":"Sheet1","row":1}},{"agencyId":"south-orange-pd","countySlug":"essex","countyName":"Essex","year":2023,"investigations":44,"allegations":{"Vehicular Pursuit Policy Violation":1,"BWC/MVR Violation":3,"Other Departmental Rule Violation":7,"Demeanor":5,"not_provided":4,"Use Of Force Policy Violation":1,"False Documentation/Falsifying A Report (Non-Criminal)":2,"Theft":1,"Harassment/Stalking":1,"Preventable MV accident":7,"Drug Test Failure":1,"Improper Supervision/Failure to Supervise":1,"Improper Entry":1,"Attendance issues":3,"Loss Of Or Failure To Safeguard Agency Propert":1,"Neglect of Duty":2,"Differential Treatment":2,"Insubordination/Disobeying An Order":1},"internalDispositions":{"Sustained":16,"Unfounded":12,"Exonerated":7,"Not Sustained":5,"not_provided":2,"Administratively Closed":2},"sustainedInvestigations":16,"sourceRef":{"file":"ia-download-2021-2023","sheet":"Sheet1","row":1}},{"agencyId":"south-orange-pd","countySlug":"essex","countyName":"Essex","year":2024,"investigations":40,"allegations":{"DUI/DWI On duty":1,"Differential Treatment":11,"Demeanor":8,"not_provided":1,"Insubordination/Disobeying An Order":4,"Other Departmental Rule Violation":12,"Attendance Issues":1,"Neglect of Duty":1,"Loss Of Or Failure To Safeguard Agency Propert":1},"internalDispositions":{"Sustained":10,"Unfounded":17,"Not Sustained":12,"Administratively Closed":1},"sustainedInvestigations":40,"sourceRef":{"file":"ia-investigations-2024-2025","sheet":"Sheet1","row":1}},{"agencyId":"south-orange-pd","countySlug":"essex","countyName":"Essex","year":2025,"investigations":35,"allegations":{"not_provided":3,"Insubordination/Disobeying An Order":4,"Other Departmental Rule Violation":10,"Conduct Unbecoming/Discredit To The Agency":2,"Demeanor":7,"Domestic violence (Non-Criminal)":1,"Preventable MV Accident":1,"Differential Treatment":5,"Loss Of Or Failure To Safeguard Agency Propert":1,"False Documentation/Falsifying A Report (Non-Criminal)":1},"internalDispositions":{"Sustained":10,"not_provided":2,"Not Sustained":7,"Unfounded":13,"Exonerated":3},"sustainedInvestigations":10,"sourceRef":{"file":"ia-investigations-2024-2025","sheet":"Sheet1","row":1}}],"officersInvolvedByYear":{"2024":40,"2025":35},"nonReportingYears":[]}}