{"url":"https://policetransparencynj.com/departments/west-milford-pd/","summary":"West Milford Police Department reported 14 internal affairs investigations in 2025 involving 10 officers. At 140 per 100 officers, the rate outpaced both the Passaic County median of 125 and the 125.9 statewide municipal median; more complaints on the books can mean more misconduct or a department that keeps a fuller record. Six of the 14 investigations detailed for 2025 reported sustained complaints. Demeanor was the leading allegation category, with Differential Treatment and Preventable MV Accident next.\n\nFour major discipline records appear across the 2020-2025 releases, from 2023, 2024 and 2025, and terminations are not reported in them. West Milford PD received a B on the report card, at the 36th percentile among 111 peers in the 30-59 officers group, a medium-confidence grade.","note":"Compiled from New Jersey Attorney General public data by an independent project; not a government source. Every value is as reported, with its sourceRef. Method: https://policetransparencynj.com/methodology/","data":{"agency":{"id":"west-milford-pd","slug":"west-milford-pd","name":"West Milford PD","fullName":"West Milford Police Department","countySlug":"passaic","countyName":"Passaic","type":"municipal-pd","aliases":["West Milford PD-Passaic","West Milford PD|Passaic"]},"totalsByYear":[{"agencyId":"west-milford-pd","countySlug":"passaic","countyName":"Passaic","year":2021,"officers":16,"investigations":19,"incidents":18,"sourceRef":{"file":"ia-agency-totals","sheet":"Sheet1","row":421}},{"agencyId":"west-milford-pd","countySlug":"passaic","countyName":"Passaic","year":2022,"officers":15,"investigations":17,"incidents":17,"sourceRef":{"file":"ia-agency-totals","sheet":"Sheet1","row":1442}},{"agencyId":"west-milford-pd","countySlug":"passaic","countyName":"Passaic","year":2023,"officers":8,"investigations":8,"incidents":8,"sourceRef":{"file":"ia-agency-totals","sheet":"Sheet1","row":1950}},{"agencyId":"west-milford-pd","countySlug":"passaic","countyName":"Passaic","year":2024,"officers":15,"investigations":16,"incidents":16,"sourceRef":{"file":"ia-agency-totals","sheet":"Sheet1","row":925}},{"agencyId":"west-milford-pd","countySlug":"passaic","countyName":"Passaic","year":2025,"officers":10,"investigations":14,"incidents":14,"sourceRef":{"file":"ia-agency-totals","sheet":"Sheet1","row":2461}}],"mdRecords":[{"id":"thomas-valente-west-milford-pd-r514","year":2025,"countyName":"Passaic","countySlug":"passaic","agencyId":"west-milford-pd","rank":"Lieutenant","firstName":"Thomas","lastName":"Valente","officerSlug":"thomas-valente-west-milford-pd","terminated":"no","demoted":"no","suspended":"no","daysSuspended":"not_reported","separatedWhileIAPending":"yes","otherSanction":"not_applicable","sustainedCharges":"Yes, Neglect of Duty, Neglect of Supervision, Violation of Dept. Dating Policy, Untruthful/Lack of Candor","description":"Lt. Valente resigned during the pendency of the IA matter, prior to a final hearing, in accordance with the terms of a settlement agreement. 2021 IA investigation determined that he had engaged in an improper relationship with subordinate P.O., relationship occurred while on duty, neglecting their assigned duties. During the course of the IA Investigation, Lt. Valente was determined to have lied to or misled the investigators about the nature of his relationship with the subordinate P.O. and the details regarding their relationship. As a result of the charges, including but not limited to, being untruthful and/or lying to IA investigators, his termination from employment was recommended. He resigned from the Dept. before charges could be finalized.","sourceRef":{"file":"major-discipline-2020-2025","sheet":"Major Discipline Data","row":514}},{"id":"james-mcmahon-jr-west-milford-pd-r1260","year":2024,"countyName":"Passaic","countySlug":"passaic","agencyId":"west-milford-pd","rank":"Officer","firstName":"James","lastName":"McMahon Jr.","officerSlug":"james-mcmahon-jr-west-milford-pd","terminated":"no","demoted":"no","suspended":"yes","daysSuspended":6,"separatedWhileIAPending":"no","otherSanction":"Loss of time","sustainedCharges":"Conduct Unbecoming: Operation of a vehicle in a reckless manner","description":"On June 8, 2022 in the early morning hours, James T McMahon Jr, while off duty, became involved in a single motor vehicle crash while negotiating a curve. Operation of the vehicle by McMahon Jr. was in a reckless manner. The conduct occurred in 2022 but the appeal was not settled until 2024. McMahon was suspended 6 (8hr) days and opted to forfeit 6 (8hr) vacation days instead of going unpaid .","sourceRef":{"file":"major-discipline-2020-2025","sheet":"Major Discipline Data","row":1260}},{"id":"james-fulton-west-milford-pd-r1859","year":2023,"countyName":"Passaic","countySlug":"passaic","agencyId":"west-milford-pd","rank":"Officer","firstName":"James","lastName":"Fulton","officerSlug":"james-fulton-west-milford-pd","terminated":"not_reported","demoted":"not_reported","suspended":"yes","daysSuspended":14,"separatedWhileIAPending":"not_reported","otherSanction":"not_reported","sustainedCharges":"Violation of Multiple Departmental Policies (C3 Mobile in car video policy, C-13 BWC policy, C-11 Cellular telephone policy)","description":"Officer Fulton responded to a single car motor vehicle crash involving an off duty officer. Officer Fulton failed to activate his mobile video recorder and body worn camera per departmental policy while at active crash scene. The conduct occurred in 2022, but the appeal became final in 2023. Officer Fulton was suspended 14 days (10 forfeited, 4 in abeyance).","sourceRef":{"file":"major-discipline-2020-2025","sheet":"Major Discipline Data","row":1859}},{"id":"jenna-bednarovsky-west-milford-pd-r1860","year":2023,"countyName":"Passaic","countySlug":"passaic","agencyId":"west-milford-pd","rank":"Officer","firstName":"Jenna","lastName":"Bednarovsky","officerSlug":"jenna-bednarovsky-west-milford-pd","terminated":"not_reported","demoted":"not_reported","suspended":"yes","daysSuspended":60,"separatedWhileIAPending":"not_reported","otherSanction":"not_reported","sustainedCharges":"Neglect of Duty, Multiple Policy Violations (C3 Mobile in car video policy, C-13 BWC policy, C-11 Cellular telephone policy, C-9 Communications Policy, Dir D2022-08 transport of persons inside police vehicles)","description":"Officer Bednarovsky responded to a single car motor vehicle crash involving an off duty officer. Officer Bednarovsky failed to activate her mobile video recorder and Body Worn Camera per departmental policy during the crash investigation. The conduct occured in 2022, but appeal became final in 2023. Officer Bednarovsky was suspended 60 days.","sourceRef":{"file":"major-discipline-2020-2025","sheet":"Major Discipline Data","row":1860}}],"benchmark":{"year":2025,"investigationsPer100Officers":140,"countyMedianPer100":125,"statewideTypeMedianPer100":125.92592592592592,"countyPeerCount":17,"statewideTypePeerCount":445},"iaDetailByYear":[{"agencyId":"west-milford-pd","countySlug":"passaic","countyName":"Passaic","year":2021,"investigations":19,"allegations":{"Improper Arrest":1,"Other Departmental Rule Violation":10,"Demeanor":5,"Differential Treatment":3},"internalDispositions":{"Sustained":11,"Unfounded":4,"not_provided":1,"Not Sustained":1,"Exonerated":1,"Administratively Closed":1},"sustainedInvestigations":0,"sourceRef":{"file":"ia-download-2021-2023","sheet":"Sheet1","row":1}},{"agencyId":"west-milford-pd","countySlug":"passaic","countyName":"Passaic","year":2022,"investigations":17,"allegations":{"Preventable MV accident":3,"Improper Arrest":1,"Demeanor":3,"Improper Supervision/Failure To Supervise":1,"Other Departmental Rule Violation":3,"Conduct Unbecoming/Discredit To The Agency":2,"BWC/MVR Violation":2,"Loss Of Or Failure To Safeguard Agency Propert":1,"Differential Treatment":1},"internalDispositions":{"Sustained":7,"Exonerated":5,"Unfounded":3,"not_provided":2},"sustainedInvestigations":6,"sourceRef":{"file":"ia-download-2021-2023","sheet":"Sheet1","row":1}},{"agencyId":"west-milford-pd","countySlug":"passaic","countyName":"Passaic","year":2023,"investigations":8,"allegations":{"Differential Treatment":2,"Loss Of Or Failure To Safeguard Agency Propert":1,"Preventable MV accident":1,"BWC/MVR Violation":2,"Conduct Unbecoming/Discredit To The Agency":1,"Other Departmental Rule Violation":1},"internalDispositions":{"Exonerated":2,"Sustained":5,"not_provided":1},"sustainedInvestigations":5,"sourceRef":{"file":"ia-download-2021-2023","sheet":"Sheet1","row":1}},{"agencyId":"west-milford-pd","countySlug":"passaic","countyName":"Passaic","year":2024,"investigations":16,"allegations":{"Other Departmental Rule Violation":2,"Domestic violence (Non-Criminal)":2,"Preventable MV Accident":4,"Demeanor":5,"Differential Treatment":2,"False Documentation/Falsifying A Report (Non-Criminal)":1},"internalDispositions":{"Not Sustained":5,"Sustained":4,"Unfounded":1,"Exonerated":5,"not_provided":1},"sustainedInvestigations":4,"sourceRef":{"file":"ia-investigations-2024-2025","sheet":"Sheet1","row":1}},{"agencyId":"west-milford-pd","countySlug":"passaic","countyName":"Passaic","year":2025,"investigations":14,"allegations":{"Differential Treatment":3,"Preventable MV Accident":3,"Demeanor":4,"Attendance Issues":1,"Neglect of Duty":1,"Domestic violence (Non-Criminal)":1,"BWC/MVR Violation":1},"internalDispositions":{"Unfounded":3,"Sustained":6,"Exonerated":4,"Not Sustained":1},"sustainedInvestigations":6,"sourceRef":{"file":"ia-investigations-2024-2025","sheet":"Sheet1","row":1}}],"officersInvolvedByYear":{"2024":16,"2025":14},"nonReportingYears":[]}}