Skip to content

Officer record · As reported by the employing agency

Nicole Stivale

Westfield Police Department · Union County

Sanction, as reported
Suspended 30 days
Year
2023
Rank, as reported
Lieutenant

1 record in the Attorney General's major discipline releases. Final, post-appeal actions, not allegations.

Lieutenant Nicole Stivale was suspended for 30 days by the Westfield Police Department in 2023. The agency reported that on January 29, 2021, Stivale was involved with the issuance of an emergency suspension of a patrol officer. A subsequent internal investigation found that the employee was improperly suspended, resulting in a sustained neglect of duty charge. The investigation also found that Stivale issued orders that directly contradicted the Chief of Police, which sustained an insubordination charge.

Major discipline records

Major discipline · 2023[1]

Suspended 30 days
Rank as reported
Lieutenant (see this rank)
Sustained charge(s)
Separated while IA pending
not reported

Synopsis as reported by the agency

On January 29, 2021, Lieutenant Nicole Stivale was involved with the issuance of an emergency suspension of a patrol officer. A subsequent internal investigation revealed that the employee was improperly suspended, resulting in sustained charges. Furthermore, the internal investigation revealed that Lieutenant Nicole Stivale issued orders that directly contradicted the Chief of Police, resulting in sustained charges.

Background: What a suspension actually means in New Jersey police discipline.

This record in context

Westfield Police Department reported 2 major discipline records for 2023: 0 with a termination, 2 with a suspension. Of 389 suspensions with a reported length in 2023, 237 were shorter than this 30-day one and 113 longer.

  • “Neglect of Duty”, in that wording: 172 records since 2020, 33 in 2023.
  • “Insubordination”, in that wording: 54 records since 2020, 19 in 2023.

Advertisement

Other officers at Westfield Police Department

2 other named officers with reported major discipline records at this agency. Major discipline is final and post-appeal, as reported by the agency.

Similar records

AnalysisComputed by this site from shared agency, year, charge category, and sanction outcome. Not a legal or factual equivalence.
  • Preston Freeman · Westfield Police Department · 2023

    Suspended 30 days

    Sustained charge(s): Neglect of Duty; Insubordination

    same agency · same year · similar charge category · similar sanction outcome

  • Justin Tracy · Audubon Police Department · 2023

    Suspended 20 days

    Sustained charge(s): Neglect of Duty / Performance of Duty / Temporary Detention Violation

    same year · similar charge category · similar sanction outcome

  • Eduardo Mena-Ramos · Bayonne Police Department · 2023

    Suspended 15 days

    Sustained charge(s): Preventable MV Crash Neglect of Duty Rule Violations

    same year · similar charge category · similar sanction outcome

  • Richard Killmer · Bayonne Police Department · 2023

    Suspended 180 days

    Sustained charge(s): Indictable Offense Conduct Unbecoming Neglect of Duty Rule Violations

    same year · similar charge category · similar sanction outcome

  • Seywonh Smith · Bergen County Sheriff's Department · 2023

    Suspended 132 days

    Sustained charge(s): 4A:2-2.3(a) 1 - Incompetency, Inefficiency or Failure to Perform Duties 4A:2-2.3(a) 3 - Inability to Perform Duties 4A:2-2.3(a) 6 - Conduct…

    same year · similar charge category · similar sanction outcome

The file behind this record

The Westfield Police Department holds the documents behind Nicole Stivale's 2023 record: the final notice or separation record, and any settlement. None has been released through OPRAmachine yet.

Request them from Town of WestfieldAn editable draft on OPRAmachine, where requests are public. Earlier requests

Compensation and pension

Retired member · NJ Treasury YourMoney[2]

This site: records-based match

Monthly pension allowance
$6,036.50
Monthly total (incl. cost-of-living)
$6,036.50
Final salary basis
$144,876
Retired
August 2023
Pension fund
Police and Firemen's Retirement System (PFRS)
Reported years of service
20 years, 4 months

How to read this

The amount is as reported by the New Jersey Department of the Treasury in its YourMoney pension data, as of September 30, 2026. It is the pension-basis figure and may not include overtime, accrued leave, stipends, or other pay. The link between this officer and this pension record is a records-based match at high confidence (matching name, exact employing agency, police-confirmed occupation, no competing candidate, and a scored match probability above the published floor; see the methodology), not a certified identity. If it is wrong, we will remove it: corrections.

Advertisement

Cite this page

Police Transparency NJ, "Nicole Stivale, Westfield Police Department," last updated 2026-11-13, https://policetransparencynj.com/officers/nicole-stivale-westfield-pd/. Source records: New Jersey Office of the Attorney General.

Questions and answers

What is a summary of Nicole Stivale's major discipline record?

Lieutenant Nicole Stivale was suspended for 30 days by the Westfield Police Department in 2023. The agency reported that on January 29, 2021, Stivale was involved with the issuance of an emergency suspension of a patrol officer. A subsequent internal investigation found that the employee was improperly suspended, resulting in a sustained neglect of duty charge. The investigation also found that Stivale issued orders that directly contradicted the Chief of Police, which sustained an insubordination charge.

What is Nicole Stivale's major discipline record at Westfield Police Department?

Nicole Stivale has one major discipline record at Westfield Police Department in the New Jersey Attorney General's 2020-2025 releases, from 2023. These are final, adjudicated actions, not allegations.

What is Nicole Stivale's pension on record?

Nicole Stivale's reported monthly pension allowance is $6,036.50, from New Jersey Treasury YourMoney data, matched to this officer at high confidence. Nicole Stivale has 20 years, 4 months of reported service.

How large is Westfield Police Department, the department Nicole Stivale worked for?

Westfield Police Department reported 63 sworn officers to the FBI for 2025. This is department-level context from the FBI's Law Enforcement Employees census, not a statement about Nicole Stivale individually.

Sources

  1. [1]New Jersey Major Discipline Data, 2020-2025. New Jersey Office of the Attorney General. Sheet "Major Discipline Data", row 1999. Snapshot retrieved 2026-10-13. ↩
  2. [2]YourMoney Retired Pension Members (PFRS/SPRS subset). New Jersey Department of the Treasury. Row 347826 (member 44321548), snapshot as of September 30, 2026. Derived from the public YourMoney Retired Pension Members dataset, https://data.nj.gov/d/nma7-ti96. ↩
  3. [3]FBI Law Enforcement Employees (LEE), New Jersey subset. Federal Bureau of Investigation. Row 8620. Derived from the public Law Enforcement Employees (LEE) / Police Employee Data dataset (1960-2025), https://cde.ucr.cjis.gov/. ↩