2 records in the Attorney General's major discipline releases. Final, post-appeal actions, not allegations.
Eavey has 2 sustained major discipline records from West Caldwell PD, spanning 2021 to 2022. The records include a suspension. Sustained charges across the records include: Policy Violation; Insubordination.
Discipline timeline, 2021 to 2022
AnalysisBar colour is this site's severity tier for the reported sanction.
2 records, 2021 to 2022
Major discipline records reported for Justin Eavey, by year
Patrolman Justin Eavey was suspended by the West Caldwell Police Department in 2022 for insubordination. The agency reported that Eavey did not follow an order to assist with traffic at an event. Because Eavey works 12 hour shifts, his suspension of 4 shifts amounted to 48 hours.
Ptl. Eavey was suspended for 4 shifts for not following an order to assist traffic at an event. Ptl. Eavey's works 12 hour shifts, therefore, his suspension was for 48 hours.
Patrol Officer Justin Eavey was suspended for 19 days by the West Caldwell Police Department in 2021. The agency reported that the suspension was for an on-duty motor vehicle accident. The sustained charge was a policy violation. The department did not provide additional detail about the incident.
West Caldwell Police Department reported no other major discipline record for 2022. Of 319 suspensions with a reported length in 2022, 8 were shorter than this 4-day one and 310 longer.
“Insubordination”, in that wording: 54 records since 2020, 15 in 2022.
Advertisement
Other officers at West Caldwell Police Department
One other named officer with a reported major discipline record at this agency. Major discipline is final and post-appeal, as reported by the agency.
Sustained charge(s): Insubordination, Training Policy & Written Directive System
same year · similar sanction outcome
The file behind this record
The West Caldwell Police Department holds the documents behind Justin Eavey's 2021 to 2022 records: the final notice or separation record, and any settlement. None has been released through OPRAmachine yet.
The amount is as reported by the New Jersey Department of the Treasury in its YourMoney pension data, as of June 30, 2026. It is the pension-basis figure and may not include overtime, accrued leave, stipends, or other pay. The link between this officer and this pension record is a records-based match at high confidence (matching name, exact employing agency, police-confirmed occupation, no competing candidate, and a scored match probability above the published floor; see the methodology), not a certified identity. If it is wrong, we will remove it: corrections.
Advertisement
Cite this page
Police Transparency NJ, "Justin Eavey, West Caldwell Police Department," last updated 2026-11-13, https://policetransparencynj.com/officers/justin-eavey-west-caldwell-pd/. Source records: New Jersey Office of the Attorney General.
Questions and answers
What is a summary of Justin Eavey's major discipline record?
Eavey has 2 sustained major discipline records from West Caldwell PD, spanning 2021 to 2022. The records include a suspension. Sustained charges across the records include: Policy Violation; Insubordination.
What is Justin Eavey's major discipline record at West Caldwell Police Department?
Justin Eavey has 2 major discipline records at West Caldwell Police Department in the New Jersey Attorney General's 2020-2025 releases, from 2021, 2022. These are final, adjudicated actions, not allegations.
What is Justin Eavey's base salary on record?
Justin Eavey's reported base salary is $140,916, from New Jersey Treasury YourMoney data, matched to this officer at high confidence. Justin Eavey has 9 years, 7 months of reported service.
How large is West Caldwell Police Department, the department Justin Eavey worked for?
West Caldwell Police Department reported 29 sworn officers to the FBI for 2025. This is department-level context from the FBI's Law Enforcement Employees census, not a statement about Justin Eavey individually.
Sources
[1]New Jersey Major Discipline Data, 2020-2025. New Jersey Office of the Attorney General. Sheet "Major Discipline Data", row 2185. Snapshot retrieved 2026-10-13. ↩
[3]Same file as [1], sheet "Major Discipline Data", row 2185. The timeline counts rows 2185, 2559. ↩
[4]YourMoney Active Pension Members (PFRS/SPRS subset). New Jersey Department of the Treasury. Row 61206, snapshot as of June 30, 2026. Derived from the public YourMoney Active Pension Members dataset, https://data.nj.gov/d/44xg-bswk. ↩
[5]FBI Law Enforcement Employees (LEE), New Jersey subset. Federal Bureau of Investigation. Row 8305. Derived from the public Law Enforcement Employees (LEE) / Police Employee Data dataset (1960-2025), https://cde.ucr.cjis.gov/. ↩